Fri 9 Nov 2007
Pay Off My Debt or Don’t and Save the Difference?
Posted by Matt WolfeFile under Saving , Investing

This is a question that many people ask. Should I take the money from my bank account and pay off my debt with it or take it and save it in my savings account earning 4-5%? My answer to this question is that it depends on the interest rate of your debt. If you carry a balance on a credit card that is getting an interest rate of 17%, you are much better off paying the balance of your credit card than you are investing the savings. It is basically like getting 17% interest on your money guaranteed. On the other hand, if you have an ultra-low interest rate of something like 3%, you are probably better off paying down the balance monthly and earning interest on your savings.
Let’s look at some numbers to get a little more in depth:
I have $10,000 in credit card debt. My credit card has an interest rate of 16%. I have $10,000 in the bank right now. Is it better to take my $10,000 and completely pay of my credit card or take that $10,000 and invest it?
If I take the $10,000 and pay off my debt, I will save myself $10,101.57 in interest payments over a ten year period.
If I take the $10,000 and put it in a savings account that earns 5% (My current savings account) and don’t touch it for ten years, I will gain $6,288.95 over that 10 years.
Clearly, it is better to pay off my credit card. I would have netted a loss of $3,812.62 over that ten year period.
Let’s start over with a 3% Interest Loan:
I have $10,000 in student loan debt. My loan has an interest rate of 3%. I have $10,000 in the bank right now. Is it better to take my $10,000 and completely pay of my student loan or take that $10,000 and invest it?
If I take the $10,000 and pay off my debt, I will save myself $1,587.29 in interest payments over a ten year period.
If I take the $10,000 and put it in that savings account that earns 5% and don’t touch it for ten years, I will gain $6,288.95 over that 10 years.
In this case, I come out ahead after 10 years by an amount of $4,701.66 by slowly paying down my student loan but investing that $10,000 in the beginning.
I really want to touch on this subject a lot more. It’s actually something that I’m just starting to learn a lot about myself. I really do hold some debt between my truck payment and my credit cards. I’m still investigating my best course of action to get them paid off and to invest my money. There are a lot more details that go in to the analysis of whether investing or paying off debt is the better solution. I’m using all these complex calculators that I’m finding on various sites and really trying to understand what they all mean. I promise I will follow up with further analysis soon. One of the great things about this blog is that it is really forcing me to learn this stuff.
Feel free to comment and/or point out flaws in my (basic) analysis.
-M
=================================================================================
The debt solution offers solution to debt problems by debt consultants with minimum amount of charges. The bad credit personal loans are not a problem any more as more and more companies are lending loans to such people with bad credit. These are payday loans without going to banks even. The consolidate debt is really helpful in reducing your debts and even getting you out of your debt faster then you estimate. The fair debt collection practices act briefs by collection dispute letters and commands to end bill collector’s illegal harassment. That means fair debt collection does not include any enforcement or assault. When debts are sent to a third party then only debt collection fees are allowed to be collected including recovery fees or expenses.
=================================================================================
Popularity: 23% [?]
Related Posts:
--Top Ten Tuesday 11/6/07 - 11/13/07
--One More Carnival Down
--Tuesday Roundup - Last One Before Christmas Edition
--Blog Action Day Recap

November 13th, 2007 at 8:21 am
One thing you are leaving out of your analysis is the fact that if you sock the $10,000 away and don’t touch it, you are still going to have to make monthly payments on your debt. So you need to calculate what happens if you pay off your debt with the $10,000 PLUS invest the amount you would otherwise be putting into your debt repayment. Otherwise, it’s not an apples-to-apples comparison.
You also need to factor in tax consequences. In the first example, paying off the credit card is even more attractive because the interest on the savings account is taxable. Student loan interest may or may not be tax-deductible, depending on the loan and your income.
November 14th, 2007 at 9:55 am
[…] I Will Be Rich: Pay Off My Debt or Don’t and Save the Difference? Honestly, I don’t always know what makes the most financial sense. I do however know that […]
November 27th, 2007 at 6:38 pm
Another thing I like to use is the Fidelity growth calculator - I use it a lot on my site - if the link doesn’t show up click my name on this link - it’ll take you there too - super helpful in figuring out these issues - I think everyone thinks about that question…
http://personal.fidelity.com/toolbox/growth/growth.shtml
November 28th, 2007 at 9:10 am
Thanks a lot Hank. That looks like a great resource. I bookmarked it. I will be sure to use that in some upcoming articles. I really appreciate that.