Mon 17 Dec 2007
Last week I wrote a post about The Secret. I received a few responses back from people and it seems like most people have a very similar opinion of the whole idea. I thought I’d share what others had to say about it and also share my thoughts on the whole concept.
A reader named Tim said;
I saw The Movie
and I was intrigued too. The whole premise of the movie is based on the law of attraction. The law of attraction says you can change the way you think and doing so will bring whatever you want into your life. To me, it is more symbolic than a known fact. It is symbolic of positive thinking, focusing, and perceiving opportunities. Be careful though, one of the characters is in trouble for taking money for investing and he spent it on himself.
Fiscal Musings said;
I also haven’t read this book, but I’ve heard a lot about it. I think they did a great marketing job by shrouding everything in secrecy, but ultimately it’s not really a new concept.
Napoleon Hill wrote a book on the subject that most people have heard of, Think and Grow Rich
. I don’t really have any desire to read this new book though.
Brip Blap said;
I have seen (and own) the DVD
, but haven’t read the book. I’m actually going to recommend Think and Grow Rich
, too, because it’s the “original” motivational book - it inspired The Secret
, Rich Dad, Poor Dad
, and a bunch of other books. My copy of it is so beat up and marked up it looks like it’s been attacked.
I doubt I’ll read The Secret
, simply because I think the DVD is probably a fair representation of the book; at least that’s my guess based on reviews I’ve read. But who knows, might be something else in there that’s not in the DVD
.
Martin Saenz said;
I’ve read the book and live the principles. Much of what is written is actually taken from “The Science of Getting Rich
” by Wallace Wattles written in 1890 or something. The Secret
does a nice job of wrapping the concept.
My thoughts:
I’ve actually had a few people recommend Think and Grow Rich to me. I think I am convinced enough to go buy it now.
As far as The Secret goes, I really like the concept. I know a lot of other people out there claim that it is B.S. or that it doesn’t work and I guess those people will just never know. The way I look at it is that it seems a little out there but what is it going to hurt. The people that are nay-sayers are not going to think positively because they don’t think it will make them successful? I think that it’s always good to think positively. If there’s really something to all of this then you will enjoy the benefits.
I don’t believe that you can have whatever you want just by thinking about it. I do believe that, by constantly thinking about something, you do whatever it takes to make sure it happens. Your mind, subconsciously, helps you figure out how to achieve your goals. This is what I believe the true secret is. Your mind is constantly working to figure out problems for you.
I have more thoughts on the whole concept and believe that a lot of this is related to Neural Linguistic Programming. You can mold your mind in to anything you want it to be. I will get more in to that topic at a later time…
Popularity: 22% [?]
Related Posts:
--The Secret
--Time For Me To Learn What You Guys Think
--Your Money or Your Life - First Impression
--My Favorite Posts Over the Past Six Months

December 18th, 2007 at 9:07 am
“I don’t believe that you can have whatever you want just by thinking about it.”
But isn’t that what The Secret teaches? As you wrote in your previous post:
“There is more complex theory behind it all. When looking at The Secret on a quantum physics level, the DVD explains that everyone and everything is made up of energy. When really broken down, everything in the universe is made up of the same thing. The concept explains that your brain sends off signals and the universe receives those signals and, ultimately, helps you get what you want.”
December 18th, 2007 at 9:47 am
I did say that’s what the book teaches. You are correct. I never said that I agreed with what the book teaches. I explained the theory behind what the book/DVD teaches in the first post. In the second post I explained what I believed. What I believe and what the book teaches are two different things…
Thanks for the comment.
December 18th, 2007 at 11:36 am
You do understand that someone might be confused when you write something like:
“As far as The Secret goes, I really like the concept.”